Avalanche defenseman Samuel Girard working against Sabres center Johan Larsson (22). Credit: Ron Chenoy-USA TODAY Sports

The Avalanche has two 19-year-olds on its roster.

Both were rushed.

Both would have been better off to have been somewhere else this season — center Tyson Jost as a sophomore in NCAA hockey with North Dakota and defenseman Samuel Girard in major junior with the Shawinigan Cataractes.

I felt even stronger about that after attending the Avalanche’s 2-1 win over the Florida Panthers Thursday night at the Pepsi Center and then the defending NCAA champion Denver Pioneers’ 1-0 squeaker against lightly regarded Dartmouth Friday night at Magness Arena.

Among the five NHL draft choices on display for the Pioneers were forwards Henrik Borgstom and Troy Terry, who both recently turned 20, and Dylan Gambrell, 21.

DU’s Henrik Borgstrom

Borgstrom is a sophomore and was claimed at No. 23 in the first round by Florida last year. Several members of the Panthers staff remained in Denver after their loss to the Avalanche to get another look at Borgstrom on the DU ice.

Terry, a junior from Highlands Ranch, went in the fifth round to Anaheim in 2015 but since has had his stock rise through heroics for the USA in the World Junior Championships and the NCAA title run with the Pioneers. Plus, he likely will be on the USA Olympic team in South Korea in February.

Gambrell, also a junior, was the 60th overall choice in 2016, going to San Jose at the end of the second round.

The point?

Borgstrom, Terry and Gambrell are getting another year of seasoning in elite college hockey, and they will be better off in the long run for it.

DU’s Troy Terry

Yes, Jost was claimed considerably earlier than any of the Pioneers, going to Colorado 13 picks ahead of Borgstrom in 2016. But even as a No. 10 overall pick, he also would have benefited from returning to North Dakota and playing there as a sophomore before signing with the Avalanche in the spring of 2018.

Instead, Jost was one and done. He played six games with Colorado at the end of last season, and his only point was his first NHL goal against Minnesota on April 6.

Girard was the 47th overall pick in that same 2016 draft, and when the Avalanche acquired him as part of the haul of four players and three draft choices in the Matt Duchene trade, he had played five games this season with Nashville. The Avalanche eagerly put him on the active roster, knowing that once he played 10 NHL games, his three-year, entry-level contract would kick in.

The option was to return Girard to Shawinigan before he played that 10th game and not burn a year of his deal.

He stayed with Colorado.

With winger Vladislav Kamenev, 21, out with a broken arm suffered in his first game with Colorado on Nov. 16, Girard is the only player on the active roster to show off  from the Duchene trade — a deal based far more on the future than the present. Center Shane Bowers, whose rights came from Ottawa, is a freshman at Boston University and goalie Andrew Hammond is in the AHL.

Now Jost and especially Girard have been struggling, at least to this extent: For the most part, they look like 19-year-olds in the NHL, and not like the few wunderkind 19-year-olds who are stars from the second they step on the ice in the top league in the world.

The Avalanche originally tossed Girard, an adept puck-moving defenseman, into the top pairing with Erik Johnson, and it worked out initially. Then Girard hit a wall and his minutes have diminished as the Avalanche, with Alexander Kerfoot out with a foot injury, have been going with seven defensemen in the lineup of late. Girard’s miscue led to the Panthers’ only goal Thursday night. In 22 NHL games this season, he has one goal and four assists and is averaging 18 minutes of ice time.

Jost has a point in each of the past two games — a goal at Washington Tuesday and an assist against Florida. But until then, he was ineffective and for the season, he has two goals and two assists in 15 games with Colorado. He missed 10 games in a 12-game span with a leg and then lower body injuries and went down to San Antonio for five games to get major ice time before being recalled Nov. 26.

The major positives, of course, are that he’s making $885,883 in the first year of his three-year deal, is in the NHL and doesn’t need to study for finals. He was eager to sign, and the Avalanche obliged.

“I don’t regret any decision I made,” he told me after practice Friday. “I don’t think that’s the way to live your life. Obviously, North Dakota’s a great spot and I loved my time there. It was a hard place to leave. But my decision was made and I’m not going to regret anything. I’m loving my time here in Colorado and I’m just trying to get my confidence right now. I’m starting to play more like myself. I’m very happy with my decision.”

What did he mean by playing like himself?

“Just kind of playing my game,” Jost said. “It was tough for the time I was out with my injury and when you’re a young guy, you want to get used to the speed and the pace and get used to kind of playing your own game in the NHL, and it’s an adjustment to be a rookie in the league. It’s tough to sit out and I’m done with injuries as an excuse because I feel like I’m finding my game, and I think you guys can see that in the last two games. I’m happy with it and I have to keep building on that., give more to the team and bring more to the table.”

When he signed, of course, the expectation was he never would play a game in the AHL, and while his stint with the Rampage about rehab and sharpening ice time, it still could have been a bit jarring.

“I think it was good for me and I think the coaching staff and the management staff did a very good job with handling things, and I think it was best for me,” Jost said. “I was out over a month, and that’s a long time to be out and not playing in any games. To get my legs back under me and get my conditioning back, it was important. When you have a lower body injury and you can’t skate, it’s tough.

“I wouldn’t say it was a wakeup call. I think it was good for me. Obviously, you hope you never go to the AHL and spend your whole career in the NHL, but it was only five games, it was fun and I worked hard and I’m not a person who’s going to go down there and sulk. I wanted to go down there, work as hard as I could and try and get back to the Avs as quick as I could, and that’s what I did.”

Girard played more than 20 minutes in seven of his first eight games with the Avalanche. But in the most recent four games, his ice time totals have been 9:16, 14:16, 12:30 and 11:14.

“I think I’ve made some good plays, but for sure, I can be better,” Girard told me Friday. “I’m having a tough month right now. Every player has tough months. I’m going to make sure I come back stronger. It’s hard for a 19-year-old defenseman, but I know I can be better and I need to have more confidence with the puck, like I had my first few games. That’s what I’m trying to do.

“My ice time is not like when I started here, but when I am on the ice, I need to play my best.”

Girard is making $728,333 in the first year of his entry-level deal. In his case, the alternative was the Quebec Major Junior Hockey League and a pro-length schedule at Shawinigan.

“I want to be here,” Girard said. “That’s how I am going to get better. Idon’t know why I would have gone back to junior. I’ve worked hard my whole life to be in the NHL.”

Colorado coach Jared Bednar said he isn’t concerned about the Avalanche possibly rushing Girard.

“I think he’s been up and down a little bit, like since he’s been here,” Bednar said. “He started out really well, he took a dip, he worked his way back in some of the games on the road trip. I think he’s doing an all right job. Honestly, he’s learning how to maneuver his way through games.

“He wants to be a difference maker. He’s used to being one of the top players on the ice probably his whole life, so this is a bit of a challenge for him. I think with that, there’s a mental side of it too. . . To be able to move on from a mistake or two and keep building confidence from the little things he does right because it’s not always going to show up on the scoresheet. I’m confident in what he can do and I think he belongs here. He’ll slowly get more ice time as he gets more comfortable.”


Player, School                            No. years played

D Erik Johnson, Minnesota                     1

C Tyson Jost, North Dakota                    1

C Colin Wilson, Boston University           2

LW J.T. Compher, Michigan                     3

LW Matt Nieto, Boston University            3

C Alexander Kerfoot, Harvard                 4


C Henrik Borgstrom, Soph., Panthers, Round 1, 2016

C Dylan Gambrell, Jr., Sharks, Round 2, 2016

D Ian Mitchell, Fr., Blackhawks, Round 2, 2017

RW Troy Terry, Jr., Ducks, Round 5, 2015

D Blake Hillman, Jr., Blackhawks, Round 6, 2016

 *    *   *

Denver-based journalist Terry Frei writes two commentaries a week about the Avalanche for Mile High Sports. He has been named a state’s sports writer of the year seven times, four times in Colorado (including for 2016) and three times in Oregon. He’s the author of seven books, including the fact-based novel “Olympic Affair” about Colorado’s Glenn Morris, the 1936 Olympic decathlon champion; and “Third Down and a War to Go,” about the 1942 football national champion Wisconsin Badgers and the players’ subsequent World War II heroism. His web site is terryfrei.com and his additional “On the Colorado Scene” commentaries are at terryfrei/oncolorado. 

E-mail: [email protected]

Twitter: @tfrei

MHS Commentary Archive:

And the Nathan MacKinnon answer is… 

Noted hockey pundit Yogi Berra would call this deja vu all over again

MacKinnon and O’Reilly meet again

Catching up with Jared Bednar

Gabe Landeskog has to be smarter, and he’s the first to say so

For Avalanche, winning back fans isn’t easy, either

Horseman/defenseman Erik Johnson up to playing marathon minutes

Ring of Famer Red Miller, Part One: Coal Miner’s son

Ring of Famer Red Miller, Part Two: About those %$#@ Raiders… 

This time a year ago, the wheels fell off 

Post-trade: On Girard and Kamenev

Matt Duchene heads to Ottawa

Stockholm is a Homecoming for Landeskog

Why Can’t MacKinnon do that every night?

And this Avalanche team is?

At the Pepsi Center, you’ll think you’re in Chicago

Is Zadorov ready to be – and stay – a top-pairing “D”?

For this is to work, Bernier has to be better

This isn’t just Jared Bednar’s second season. It’s his second chance.

Sven (The Reindeer) Andrighetto speedily skating into Avalanche forefront

With Avalanche off to another 3-1 start, leadership is a “core” issue