No. 5 – Andrew Luck

The Colts are 3-3, sitting atop an awful division in the AFC South. However, Luck is a mere 1-3 with his lone win coming by squeaking past the Tennessee Titans in Week 3. After missing back-to-back games with a shoulder injury, Luck played his best game of the season against the New England Patriots last week in a loss. Still, he hasn’t been up to the standards we expect from him.

As Troy Renck points out, “Five games in, Andrew Luck and Peyton Manning, who finished first and second in TD passes last year, have more INTs than TDs this year.”

The Colts only face four teams currently with a winning record in their remaining 10 games. Luck is in prime position to get back on track as he leads his team to another division title.